Dead Sea Scrolls

What is the “Wizard of Oz” of Biblical Studies Articles?

It is a little known fact – at least it was to me – that The Wizard of Oz (1939) is the most quoted and alluded to movie of all time. Think of how many times you hear lines like “Well Toto, we’re not in Kansas any more!”, “There’s no place like home”, “I’ll get you my pretty…” and “I’m melting!”

If we applied the same criteria to articles in the field of biblical studies, which article would be the most cited? Well, my suggestion is this article by Samuel Sandmel:

If we applied the same criteria to articles in the field of biblical studies, which article would be the most cited? Well, my suggestion is this article by Samuel Sandmel:

Samuel Sandmel, “Parallelomania,” Journal of Biblical Literature 81 (1962): 1-13.

Not only have I seen it cited many times but it deserves credit for adding a new word to the English theological dictionary. Sandmel writes:

We might for our purposes define parallelomania as that extravagance among scholars which first overdoes the supposed similarity in passages and then proceeds to describe source and derivation as if implying literary connection flowing in an inevitable or predetermined direction.

Surely the exhortation to avoid the error of parallomania is as valid today as it was in 1962?

Perhaps you have a nomination for the title – I’d love to hear it.

Many thanks the Society of Biblical Literature for their kind permission to reproduce this article.

Rob

Share
Published by
Rob

Recent Posts

New College Library, Edinburgh University

The Association of British Theological and Philosophical Libraries held their Spring Conference in Edinburgh at…

5 days ago

Just published: Unity in the Book of Isaiah, edited by Rossi, Irudayaraj & Hens-Piazza

I have always been fascinated by the arguments for and against the unity of the…

2 weeks ago

Rutherford Centre for Reformed Theology – Final Newsletter

Rutherford Centre for Reformed Theology is closing and merging with the Highland Theological College (pictured…

4 weeks ago

Gospel of Matthew – H.U. Weitbrecht – Indian Church Commentary

Today's free book is Herbert Udny Weitbrecht's commentary on the Gospel of Matthew, part of…

2 months ago

Theology on the Web New Year 2024 Update

One of the advantages of working for an educational institution is that you do get…

3 months ago

New Journal Alert! Theological Student Fellowship Bulletin (US) Now Online

In 2013 I received permission from InterVarsity (USA) to digitise and host their 1980s student…

4 months ago